The following persons have served as officially appointed postmasters of the Vestal Centre Post Office.
William Gordon, 1851 - 1854 Albert R. Ellis, 1854 - 1855 Arad Platt, 1855 - 1857 Jesse Burrows, 1857 - 1859 Ryas W. Price, 1859 - 1863 Samuel Chamberlain, 1863 - 1870 John H. Day, 1870 - 1872 Daniel M. Clark, 1872 - 1877 Henry V. Batcher, 1877 - 1886 William B. Hillygus, 1886 - 1889 Augustus W. Aldrich, 1889 - 1893